An elegant rule for a more civilized age
An elegant rule for a more civilized age
31 comments
-
-
-
Stargate is one word, it's bothering me a perhaps unreasonable amount.
-
Chapa I
-
Dja far!
-
open the irish
-
-
-
When in doubt... C4
-
"Explosive placed!"
-
-
Diplomacy usually comes before the pew pew for Trek and the sonic moves the scene along without solving the problem in its entirety for The Doctor.
-
I fell out of love with Doctor Who when I realized all the sci-fi bits were complete made-up bullshit. Kinda the same reason I don't much care for Star Wars.
Star Trek is at least plausible if far-fetched, and Stargate actually tries to make the technobabble compatible with theoretical physics, which is a major reason I've come to adore it.
And I came to hate the writing of Doctor Who because it has the same problem as BBC's Sherlock (which makes sense as they shared showrunners and writing staff): they make the main character seem clever by figuring out the mystery before the viewer, but only because they deliberately hide or obfuscate key details until they're ready for the big reveal. So the solution feels less like a brilliant show of deduction and more like a batshit insane ex Machina.
-
Star Wars just isn't sci-fi. Its technology should be treated the same way one treats magic in a fantasy story. Because that's what it is: a fantasy story. It's just space fantasy, rather than the more typical mediaeval or urban fantasy genres.
Sherlock Holmes is kinda meant to be that way. It's not the BBC version's fault, that's just faithful adaptation. Sherlock isn't meant to be a mystery series in the style of an Agatha Christie novel. It's more of a character study of a character so different from normal people. It's ok not to like Sherlock Holmes or adaptations of it (gods know...there's plenty of criticism out there for the BBC adaptation), but if you dislike it because it breaks Knox's rules of detective fiction, that's because you went into it with entirely the wrong expectations, rather than because it's poor storytelling.
-
-
-
I still argue the sonic screwdriver opening doors is more elegant than the lightsaber. Usually after the fact, the door can be closed and locked again.
-
C4 is the most elegant way of opening doors out of the four… there is no door, doorframe, or wall left after usage. You’ve kinetically remodeled the room!
-
-
cries in Zat'nik'tel
-
It's driving me crazy that the TNG officer has the TOS phaser, and the 10th Doctor has the 11th's screwdriver.
-
That's also Ben solo with Anakin Skywalker's saber.
-
Yeah, I thought that looked wrong, but I couldn't tell for sure which lightsaber that was, and I wasn't even 100% that was supposed to be a picture of Kylo Ren, so I just stuck to what I was sure of.
-
-
-
All of these < Farscape < Babylon 5 < Cleopatra 2525
-
Cleopatra 2525 is the greatest!
-
-
The snake scepter thingies the Goa'uld use are basically those
-
Did you just refer to a goa'uld staff weapon as a snake sceptre?
-
Snek stik pew pew
-
-
-
-
Go away, bot
-
-
31 comments