Utah study on trans youth care extremely inconvenient for politicians who ordered it
Utah study on trans youth care extremely inconvenient for politicians who ordered it
The state’s ban on gender-affirming pediatric care “cannot be justified” by science, a two-year review concluded.
But according to the Salt Lake Tribune, legislators behind the ban are already dismissing the findings they asked for.
Of course they are. They never believed in science. It's why they have so many anti-vaxxers in their camp. They tried to lean on it (science) because they hoped it would legitimize their hateful beliefs. It's not difficult to throw it away when it doesn't come out on their side.
They’ve been lying about what gender affirming care for kids looks like, why would they tell the truth about anything? There’s a coordinated effort to platform fake detransitioners, to claim that kids are getting handed out surgery and hormones willy nilly, to pretend that adult trans people don’t exist.
Arguing with these people is like trying to hold sand. They start with “I don’t want trans people to exist” and work backwards.
Utah doesn't have a great track record of following the science. Especially if they are "moved by the Holy Ghost."
Not an American.
Utah is where the Amish live, isn't it?
No, Mormons.
The Amish, chiefly found in Pennsylvania and Ohio, mainly keep to themselves, making delicious cheeses and maple syrup.
Mormonism is a religion founded in the late 1800’s by a guy named Joseph Smith who used to do fortune telling by “seeing” through rocks. He “found” some golden plates which were written in “Reformed Egyptian,” which no one else got to see. He “translated” them using the magic stones and the help of the Angel Moroni, and found that they had a story about Jesus coming to the Americas to teach the Native Americans who turn out to be the Lost Tribes of Israel. (It’s just a coincidence that his book seems to have a lot of ideas in common with a fiction book written around the time, and that “it came to pass” and other BoMism’s sound just like someone trying to write like the King James Bible.)
He later had a revelation from God that the only way to get to heaven was to marry lots of women, especially teenage girls. God made sure to send him a message to forward to his wife about how this was okay and she had to accept it or god wouldn’t be happy with her.
He also bought an Egyptian papyrus off of a PT Barnum type (may even have straight up been Barnum, been a billion years since I read Fawn Brodie’s No Man Knows My History) to translate that “Reformed Egyptian” into the “Book of Abraham.” This was before the discovery of the Rosetta Stone, so no one had any idea how to translate Egyptian hieroglyphs yet. (That papyri was lost for a century, but later discovered hidden in a picture frame. It was a mutilated Egyptian Book of the Dead.)
The Mormons had a tendency of pissing everyone off, and got chased out of Missouri (where the Garden of Eden is) and Illinois. Smith himself was killed in jail. They moved to Utah, where they could have as many child wives as they wanted. (Everyone forgets that the Republican Party was originally founded to oppose “the two barbarisms” - slavery and polygamy.) Brigham Young took the child wife thing to the next level, and also added lots more racism. (Black people are souls that sat out the original battle in heaven between Jesus and Satan. If they are really good they get to be servants on a white persons paradise planet after they die. Black Mormons couldn’t have the priesthood until the 1970’s - which all adult Mormon men need the priesthood to save their own families.)
They did eventually give up the polygamy because they wanted statehood (on earth - but guys still get extra spirit wives on their heaven planet.)
The current Church, like Scientology, is a real estate grift (they own billion dollar malls.) They also were responsible for things like Prop 8/attacking gay marriage in the late naughts.
Mormans: The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-Day Saints
Edit: speling
Nah Utah is Mormons. Amish are in Pennsylvania and Ohio
They forgot to rig it.
But seriously, the response is disgusting. This is a report you requested, using experts seeking genuine truth. The goal was to improve lives and understand the effects of treatment. There are ethical reasons one could reject a report saying it's not good, namely bodily autonomy and individual freedom, but when the evidence comes back that you shouldn't restrict this individual freedom, that's pretty heinous to do so.
You forgot the tiny detail that their feelings don't care about facts.
Oh what was that saying the Trump crowd was so proud of but can't stand when it's said back to them...
Oh right.
Facts don't care about their feelings, but their feelings don't care about facts either.
Who would you rather believe, my man-made book about our magical friend in the sky or some stupid data driven peer reviewd scientific study?
I mean, it isn't as though politicians are above fabricating a bunch of medicalized Trans bigotry. The UK's Cass Report is one such example.
What's amazing is that Utah's researchers did the leg work properly, rather than conducting a series of FOX News style interviews and Steven Crowder inspired trolling.
Someone should force Keir Starmer and the UK Government to read this report. They have been bad but they may not be quite as far gone as the Republicans.
Wait Nazis aren't rational and just?
Well they more I hear about them, the less I like em.
Since when did Republicans give a rats ass about science?
In the off-chance it doesn't totally disprove them.
"hey we didn't say anything about science... did you guys order the wrong kind of study? i meant like bible study"
Look, if we ban science; no more pesky facts getting in our way. /s
Good job there’s more than 20 other studies out there for them to p-hack
When Roald Reagan pushed tax cuts for the rich George W. Bush called it 'voo-doo economics.'
In almost five decades, the taxcuts have never paid for themselves as reagan promised.
Funny since they both were propped up by the heritage foundation.
Reagan was president 1981-1989. During years 1981-2023, there were only 5 years (1982, 1991, 2008, 2009, 2020) where US growth was less than 1%. I don't know enough to say whether that's thanks to or despite Reagan, but he sure didn't destroy the economy.