3w ago

Man serves only four days in jail for crushing the pelvis of woman he suspected of being trans

montanafreepress.org Man agrees to plead no contest to charge of assaulting person he believed to be trans

Prosecutors have agreed to drop a felony charge and will not seek jail time for a man who in 2023 drove his pickup into a person, pinning her against a Great Falls bar, after yelling at her about being transgender.

Transgender @lemmy.blahaj.zone

Sunshine (she/her) @lemmy.ca

2w ago

Man agrees to plead no contest to charge of assaulting person he believed to be trans

montanafreepress.org /2025/02/04/man-agrees-to-plead-no-contest-to-charge-of-assaulting-person-he-believed-to-be-trans/

22 0

22 comments

The prosecutor: "Based upon the way the incident occurred, it looked to me like a guy who was a little under the influence, thought he had it in reverse and he actually had it in drive"
- Whomst among us hasn't drunkenly committed a hate crime in our f3500 max super pickup?
- Holy shit you weren’t doing a bit they actually fuckin said that
- Montana is just 3 drunk drivers and a cow in a trenchcoat.
  
  A cow would never
- Prosecutors when hate crime: "I think it was just an honest fuck-up, bro."
  Prosecutors when they can pad their resume with a poor person's life over loitering or some bullshit: " I AM THE DEVIL, AND I AM HERE TO DO THE DEVIL'S WORK!!!"
- The law isn't being applied inconsistently if you consider who these laws were designed to punish.
- Pit

transphobes love to claim they are "protecting" (cis) women. and then they do this shit

this is fucking crazy, this reminds me of Nex Benedict, they've been just literally shouting to the skies for years now that its legal to kill us.
get a fucking gun, now, these people will beat you and break you and WILL get away with it. We need to defend ourselves from them.

Tf?!

His name is John P. Carr and this is the image of him at the Cowboys Bar in Great Falls:

The victim was seriously injured with a fractured pelvis and a puncture wound in her thigh. Emergency responders found her on the ground, in severe pain with “fluid” coming out of their mouth, according to charging documents.
Court documents indicate he will receive credit for spending four days in jail after his arrest, but he has otherwise been out on bond throughout the case
According to the plea, Carr will receive a five-year suspended sentence, which means he will serve no additional jail time.
I never want to hear a single honkey talk about India ever again
- lmao I forgot this gem
  John P. Carr, 59, agreed to plead no contest to criminal endangerment
  I can't tell if virtue signalling how much you hate women, or choosing the lowest possible charge so it sticks. I guess he put the victim in a "criminally endangering" situation by ramming her with his car. And even that didn't stick, a failed state

I spent 28 days in jail for my first offense DUI

Wow. I wonder if these folks realize that literally the entire point of the government having an exclusive monopoly on violence is so people don't feel the need/permission to take action themselves. Well, shit, get a gun while you still can and protect yourself, because clearly the government won't. Better to be tried by 12 than carried by 6.

They do say if you want to commit a crime, do it with a car.

Am I reading this right? It looks like he’s serving 5 years with the 4 days figure being time he served before he got out on bail.
- It's a suspended sentence, he won't go to prison uness he violates probation. So he's getting 4 days + probation.

22 comments