Proton domains blocked as disposable in disposable filter
Proton domains blocked as disposable in disposable filter
github.com
Please remove ProtonMail domains · Issue #422 · wesbos/burner-email-providers
I hope it is a way to solve this…
38 comments
-
-
deleted
-
Disposable mails (one time mails) can be a problem for webmasters. But PRIVACY mails or ALIAS mails is PERMANENT addresses. So there is no way that they would be deleted at no additional situation. They gonna be deleted only if webmaster send SPAM or got data leak.
If you will use such addresses as disposable you will be simply banned (there is written in ToS)
-
-
It's a rare treat to see somebody raise a concern while at the same time doing something (PR + discussion). Kudos to you!
I've seen other similar lists with the same issues (c7 I think?).
This is going to be a mesh if all private email providers are blocked.
-
Okay why do these random packages keep popping up with this? For attention?
It's irrelevant, they are barely used by anyone and if a site blocks legitimate e-mail providers, then it is not a site worth registering with in the first place.Is this the new interaction bait post?
-
Just because not many people use a package, doesn't mean it is irrelevant. For open source packages (or anything really), as soon as one additional person uses a package, that package becomes relevant. The person/people using it become its advertisers, and when enough people are seen using a product, especially a free one, a larger group will use either that package or something similar to cut their own programming costs.
This is simplified, but the point is that we need to stop this sort of thing at the root (the package itself) before it gets noticed by larger groups and companies who might actually get away with this BS. Always remember, we are tech/privacy nerds. We are the minority, and the average person doesn't care until something hurts them directly.
-
-
It is logical that large corporations that base their economy on surveillance advertising hate users who protect their privacy by using all kinds of dirty tricks to bypass or eliminate these protections.. Luckily I have had no problems so far with the Proton, Tuta and Murena (NextCloud) emails that I use in the EU.
-
Unfortunately? This is true. That’s why I asked help from community!
-
Try with Murena, the NextCloud mail (xxxx@e_email direction), it's maybe less known by these lists.
-
-
-
-
Look. Outlook, Yahoo, ICloud, even Gmail provides temp mails solutions, but nobody complains or blocks them.
Also you can use something like this that will create disposable Gmail every time. So blocking Proton is totally useless
-
But good on you for trying to get it out of the blacklist.
I saw tutanota was in there as well.
-
-
Ugh. I don't like i this evolution. Simple login is pretty handy to avoid jumping through hoops to unsub from companies.
Recently had a site where I bought something once without having to register spamming me with Christmas mails. If I wanted to unsubscribe from the mailing list I had to register before I could unsub.
Just deleting the simplelogin alias is a lot less work than unsubscribing is most of the time... And my actual email address isn't leaking either so... Profit.
-
Your can simply block sender, not only delete aliases. So it is a problem of webmaster that doesn’t respect users wish to unsubscribe
-
-
It's said in the thread you've linked that they have already been removed from the blocklist.
-
Unfortunately no. See here
-
-
Ironically, when I tried setting a ProtonMail account recovery email address, they rejected it because it was on a list like this one. I hope Proton gets off this blacklist, but I also think they should practice what they preach.
-
They rejects them because it is an abuse prevention mechanism. You can solve captcha and register without any additional information
-
They rejects them because it is an abuse prevention mechanism.
An "abuse prevention mechanism" that punishes legitimate users is a badly designed mechanism. It's a lot like police racial profiling.
You can solve captcha and register without any additional information
Nobody said anything about registering.
-
-
-
What is this? Does anybody actually use it?
-
Yes. That’s why I asked help :(
-
38 comments
It's not just Protonmail.
Blacklists like these aggressively and unapologetically collect all privacy-focused email domains they find, including simple forwarding and tagging services. With more and more sites using these lists to reject or black-hole email addresses, it has become difficult to protect one's self from spam and cross-site account tracking.
Dear web developers, please don't use these lists. Well-intended or not, they are privacy and user-hostile.
That’s not what this specific list is for.
AWS SES, for example, is fucking rabid about bounces. Being able to filter out addresses you know are going to bounce is pretty important.
Can a list like this be used for anti-privacy measures? Absolutely! Does that mean we should never create lists like this? For me that depends on whether or not you think we should prevent encryption because bad actors can use it for bad purposes.
I feel like having different attributes for each domain might be helpful so that those services using the list can filter for just the things they care about such as burner emails, anonymous registration, whether it requires any email/phone verification, etc. Right now domains kind of have the problem of just being on the list or not, with no indication on why they might be a problem.
Yet it has a lot of legitimate domains, and has had them for years.
Regardless of whether the maintainer is malicious or just irresponsible, his list is doing harm.
Devs can use them to block DISPOSABLE mails, not PRIVACY legitimate emails. That’s why it is critical to remove privacy oriented email domains from such lists
That's what they claim, but in practice, they seldom distinguish between the two.