I remember that shit. Honestly, madden 2005 and NFL 2K5 were both fire football games and it was a pretty close split over arguing which was better at the time. EA and the NFL went pretty hard on sucking cock with going exclusive. Really trashed making anything creative or new from that point on.
Honestly the NCAA football games from 05 (2004 on) onwards have always been much more interesting football games over madden. 2K5 is a really good nfl game, but I honestly rather dick around in the NCAA football's dynasty mode than 2k5's franchise mode.
Totally! I had no idea that it was EA's fault that it disappeared. I picked it up for every system I ever had. I think Dreamcast was the last one for me.
One thing I hate about sports games is they don't design based on real world stats nor create a huge library of players and teams. For example, a game character's speed is determined by the average number of yards a player ran per play in real life. Or their accuracy in catching the ball. Toss in a good physics engine that calculates their mass ramming into a player with less mass to determine how a tackle plays out.
Do this for every player every year and you have a really cool fantasy football (or whatever sport) sim. Make a stacked team from the best players of that year to dominate a season. Make a roster from the worst players and try to win by having better plays. Even better? You can mix and match players from different years or eras. Have Michael Jordan and Shaq on your 2013 Lakers team. Play Brett Favre, Tom Brady, and Don Hutson in the Chicago Bears.