1y ago

Alpha Phi Alpha's transgender ban is a step backward for a fraternity founded to move our community forward

www.advocate.com

15 comments

It was a pointless move on their part as well. Virtue signalling in the shittiest way possible. Make it cost them.
The article doesn't really elaborate on what they mean by a "transgender ban"...
There is this section:
Despite there being transgender and nonbinary members in our organizations, no Black fraternity or sorority has a truly gender-inclusive policy, especially for people who transition after initiation. Coming into your gender identity does not equate to wanting to stop affiliation with the organization. But stepping back from our organizations is usually a byproduct of little to no pro-inclusion policies.
Which seems to imply that the issue is with people who are initiated (as men) and then transition away (and no longer are men). If this is the case, it seems a lot less egregious. Just like sororities are organizations by and for women, fraternities are organizations by and for men.
Whilst it may seem unfair, losing access to gendered spaces of the gender someone is transitioning away from is, in a way, a recognition of their new identity.
- The definition being adopted is:
  any male defined as a human being naturally born male, who remains and continually identifies as a male,
  https://glaad.org/glaad-exclusive-alpha-phi-alpha-fraternity-considers-transgender-ban/
- It seems that this fraternity would exclude trans men based on the rule quoted in the article.
- Would many trans women want to stay in the fraternity after transitioning?
  On the one hand, it feels mean to force them out, especially with how close people in a group like that can be. But on the other hand, if the goal is fraternity, is the frat still meeting the trans person's needs? Is it meeting the needs of the remaining group?
  Either way, this really feels like something each chapter should be able to handle on a case by case basis -- I can't imagine there's enough trans people transitioning at that time where you need a fixed rule for it.
TIL that fraternities are still relevant.
I thought they were a relic of a bygone era.
"Organization founded on gender discrimination adopts discriminatory gender policy"
Fuck APA.
Fraternities are a step backwards.
They voted.
Either the majority of these young men attending college are transphobic or there's quite a few things the angry mob doesn't care to understand.
- What the actual fuck of a whiffle waffle comment is this?
  Banning transgender members is transphobic.
- If for you trans men are women, you're transphobic. It's that simple.
- All ears. Go ahead...

15 comments