Skip Navigation
Top senators believe the US secretly recovered UFOs
  • If your argument comes down to "you don't have the evidence to prove a negative" that's a pretty strong indicator that your argument is weak. People saying something isn't proof. If one is to make expansive claims there should be evidence to support those claims.

  • Israelis critical of the government
  • The problem with your assessment is here:

    "Suddenly, there was an attack and all dissatisfaction with Likud and Netanyahu vanished."

    Very much this is not the case. The removal of Netanyahu is a slow process but his lasting support primarily was based on his promise of domestic security for Israelis and that has obviously disappeared. Democracy is a slow process.

  • House approves sell-or-be-banned TikTok measure, attaching it to foreign aid bill
  • Nothing in the article cites a reason for why the data was sent. In fact the article specifically mentions that this data being sent was to circumvent attempts to limit the transmission of American citizens data to a hostile foreign government.

    We should ban the sale and transmission of Americans sensitive data to hostile foreign powers regardless of the company. I support this action because it would help do that, and I would support (and I do advocate for) more broad data privacy legislation. If you support data privacy why would you not support a bill which enhances data privacy, even if it doesn't go far enough?

    You started this discussion with me by saying that tiktok isnt obligated to send data, when I provided sourcing to that effect you brought up corporate structure questions asking if the data was being sent. I provided a source showing that it is transmitted through those avenues regardless. Now your argument is that because we don't have totally comprehensive data privacy regulation we can just ignore the fact that tiktok is sending American citizens private data to a hostile foreign power? If you think that isn't a big deal just say so, then we can have an honest conversation.

  • House approves sell-or-be-banned TikTok measure, attaching it to foreign aid bill
  • Attempts have been made. But the data is still sent.

    https://www.theverge.com/2024/4/16/24132315/tiktok-bytedance-project-texas-china-silo

    We should have better and more comprehensive data privacy laws across the board but whataboutism doesn't change the fact that tiktok is obligated to share Americans data with a hostile and repressive foreign power.

  • House approves sell-or-be-banned TikTok measure, attaching it to foreign aid bill
  • https://www.rfa.org/english/news/afcl/fact-check-tiktok-03242023144611.html

    Technically according to this article tiktok won't share data with the PRC - but their parent company bytedance is obligated to share data with the PRC when requested. Bytedance has authority to require tiktok to share data. Therefore through this channel tiktok is obligated to share data with the PRC when requested.

  • Biden trolls Trump for boasting about golf trophies: ‘Quite the accomplishment’
  • I agree with the sentiment but I also want to say that the DNC doesn't choose the nominee in the way the person you are replying to thinks. No candidate who has a credible chance of being present decided to run in the primary. We can't just hope that a shadowy backroom DNC deal (which only exists in the minds of those without a sophisticated understanding of us party politics) to force a whittmer or newsom or any other democrat in a position to run a national campaign to actually run for president. Political leaders make their own choice if they want to run and while that choice is influenced by party insiders and any other number of factors but at the end of the day of all candidates who decided to run for the democratic nomination - Biden is the most credible and capable candidate. The DNC can't just pick a name and run them.

  • UN Security Council resolution calls for Gaza ceasefire
  • It's true that far right Israeli settlers need to stop killing families to take their land. But Hamas has little presence in the West Bank and the issues are not fundamentally linked. Progress needs to be made to stop the settlement of the West Bank (pressure on bibi and sanctions on settlers) and on the need to stop attacks from Hamas on Israeli civilians + the release of hostages. But progress on one of these fronts does not need to be linked to the other.

  • Hamas rejects Israel’s offer of two-month pause in Gaza fighting — Egyptian official
  • Israel should stop settlements in the West Bank because its the right thing to do. However if I were a Palestinian in Gaza and a peace deal was derailed because Hamas was refusing to agree without West Bank settlement concessions I'd be pretty pissed.

    That being said given that Hamas broke the last ceasefire agreement, and their stated goal is to conduct other attacks like Oct 7th, I'm not sure how a ceasefire could be reached even on narrow grounds.

  • Hamas rejects Israel’s offer of two-month pause in Gaza fighting — Egyptian official
  • Given that Hamas does not operate in the West Bank I'm dubious that what you are describing in a West Bank hypothetical would occur. Illegal settlements in the West Bank are awful and should be stopped by Israel - but they are not directly tied to the current conflict with Hamas.

  • Overdraft fees could drop to as low as $3 under new Biden proposal
  • Perhaps if you aren't interested in reading analysis by others you might want to consider why your response is a multi paragraph answer justifying why a good news headline is actually bad and confirms your priors that Biden and Democrats are bad. I think this comment is a pretty perfect example of bad faith arguments.

  • Biden’s Strikes in Yemen Are Unconstitutional, Bipartisan Members of Congress Say
  • Yes this is a useful Wikipedia article. Especially the point just a little past the first line which specifically rebuts the point you are making:

    "The territorial sea is sovereign territory, although foreign ships (military and civilian) are allowed innocent passage through it, or transit passage for straits"

    And just to jump ahead to preempt your next argument, innocent passage is defined in the UN convention on the law of the sea here:

    https://www.un.org/depts/los/convention_agreements/texts/unclos/part2.htm

    Furthermore the Houthis are not making claims that the vessels attacked are violating innocent passage. Only you are for some reason.

  • Younger Americans are friendlier to China
  • One has to understand internal CCP politics through very imprecise measures, but one key thing to look at factional power within the CCP. Xi, by all accounts, has managed to suppress and marginalize all other factions within the party. This can be seen in the tangible result of his norm breaking additional term(s?) as leader of the party.

  • InitialsDiceBearhttps://github.com/dicebear/dicebearhttps://creativecommons.org/publicdomain/zero/1.0/„Initials” (https://github.com/dicebear/dicebear) by „DiceBear”, licensed under „CC0 1.0” (https://creativecommons.org/publicdomain/zero/1.0/)LY
    Lynthe @sh.itjust.works
    Posts 0
    Comments 26