Emulation @lemmy.ml Jediwan @lemy.lol 7 mo. ago

Emulation community expresses defiance in wake of Nintendo’s Yuzu lawsuit

arstechnica.com Emulation community expresses defiance in wake of Nintendo’s Yuzu lawsuit

"EmuDev" coders cite precautions, legal differences they say will offer protection.

34 comments

Yuzu source

Cant help but think Nintendo's actions are too little too late now. That cat is out of the bag. About all they can do now is break compatibility on new releases.
- They can't really break compatibility though. Because the keys are baked into the hardware and the rest of the hardware is, well, hard. Unless you're talking about Switch 2, which would of course work for Switch 2 games.
  
  I just assumed they would blacklist the publicly available encryption keys and/or push an update that adds another security layer and has to be installed for new games to play. But I'm not super familiar with nintendo emulation so this may not be plausible.
- You assume this is about the switch, which is at end of life more or less. Its about the Switch 2.
  
  Yeah I'm guessing the switch 2 is going to be the switch but slightly more powerful, using similar hardware to maintain compatibility with older switch titles. Meaning their new console is likely going to be able to be emulated at or very shortly after launch. Instead of competing on features, like upscaling, mod support, third party peripherals, etc, they've decided to sue people until the problem vanishes. So classic corpo Nintendo dumbshittery.
  
  I own ToTK and 2 switches. I still emulate it. Nintendo your hardware is hot ass, your controllers have major drift issues, your online service is barely functional, and I don't want to pay to back up my own goddamn saves.
I see one of two things happening.

Yuzu team calls it quits and throws in the towel due to insufficient funds.

It goes to court and Nintendo wins due to the judge being technically illiterate and takes Nintendo's side because they appear more professional and legitimate.

I would love for them to challenge and beat this but I think it would require a very knowledgeable legal team such as those who work with the EFF or some similar organization.
- It probably won’t make it to court because the devs cant afford it. Nintendo likely wouldn't win, it is just bullying them into shutting down.
Didn't they use an emulator in the nes classic or some product?
- Yeah the nes and snes classic, also nintendo switch online gives you access to some nes, snes, n64, and gameboy/gba games with emulation.
  
  They’ve stolen open source (or at least free) emulators for their own commercial releases in the past too, haven’t they?
  
  It was the same with the Wii too.
Interesting read, but a misleading title.

Most of the emulation developers basically said "no shit, maybe don't help pirates steal a game that isn't even on sale yet (referring to Yuzu supporting Tears of the Kingdom the day before it released)".
- I thought Yuzu specifically did not support TotK until it was released (in New Zealand).
- They only supported it because their emulator works, no game specific patches were published until the game was released and properly bought by the devs (and they were fairly strict on this in the discord)
Is Yuzu open source? What stops people from copying it and re-releasing it under a new name?
- Nothing, that's not the point. The point is that the developers stop work on it and eventually it stops working. Then the Switch 2 comes out and Switch 2 games cannot be emulated. Nobody thinks that Yuzu, in the current state, will stop being available.
  
  But if it’s open source, can’t someone else fork the project and continue?
Anyone else sitting right on the edge with Nintendo and this shit? It's like Lego and plastic ocean trash, how the fuck are these folks avoiding pitchforks?
- Lego gets a pass in my books. I don't think I've ever seen a piece of Lego on the ground or washed up at the beach.
  
  Nintendo can suck it. Though I'll give them credit for using outdated hardware because that makes their games easy to emulate.
  
  I have LEGO bricks over 25 years old which still work perfectly fine. Such long lasting plastic products are definitely not the cause of plastic pollution in nature, plastic is not inherently bad.
Legit question. How did the author of the emulator even got identified? How does Nintendo keeps suing these people? Do they just sign their own name on their git or something like that?
- Nintendo is not suing individual developers, they are suing the company that was set up. But besides that, I doubt they took any efforts to hide themselves.
  
  They were apparently very plainly bragging about how they were directly distributing ROMs, something that is quite blatantly illegal.
I think they should stick to emulating non current platforms.
- Nyo company should just make sure all there games get pc release instead plus server software self host multiplayer if they shutdown official servers then we wouldnt nyeed to make emulaters in the first place

You've viewed 34 comments.