I honestly think AI image generation is fundamentally useless if it's too heavily controlled to prevent negative press. It's shit anyway, but it's so god damn annoying having to dance around the ten bazillion different things they're censoring for liberal sensibilities.
It fundamentally makes it impossible to create anything provocative with it, and that's literally what any actually good art has always been. Same goes for memes and shit. The good ones are always riding some sort of edge.
Funny side story: ChatGPT 3.5 refuses to recognize Palestine as living under apartheid. If you ask it what are the conditions of apartheid, it will list them clearly and use South Africa & Jim Crow U.S. as examples. If you ask it if Palestine fits the same criteria it just laid out, it will agree, but will refuse to say it definitively, only responding with a million different variants of "it's a complex issue."
AI bros should have to do prison time with hard labor.
What great harm is being prevented by keeping me from making spacesuit Hitler on a toilet blasting off in a cloud of diarrhea?
It’s really clear that the point of the guardrails is to cover up the fact that all the models are trained on insanely racist datasets to begin with and even without the explicit racism in the datasets it would draw back the curtain on exactly how fascist modern liberalism has become by dint of its MO, figure out a visual representation of what you’re looking for and show it to you.
Surprise, the aryan mommy milkers machine can’t be trusted to present history!
it would draw back the curtain on exactly how fascist modern liberalism has become
For who though? Surely not the vast majority people within the imperial core who would see nothing wrong with it. Is it just the fair trade coffee problem? Liberals not wanting to feel guilty?
imo it’s a great example of the whole “liberals are conservatives and conservatives are liberals” thing. They go back and forth in a race to the bottom to make this tech useless because they’re both constantly petitioning to make it behave as inoffensively as possible.
I remember I once cried over a blind casting of Shakespeare. I kept telling them that they needed to have Braille scripts but they just wouldn't listen to me
AI is so unfathomably fucked because unless companies like google permanently prefix every query with "ethnically ambiguous", it will never generate people of colour unless you ask them to generate images of a litter picker or something; the AI itself is white supremacist and this is their solution to it
Take these, Gordon, you can use them to generatestaticElectricity. Server boards are highly susceptible to a localized minor increase of the electromagnetic force.
Remember the wave of conservatives trying to do a gotcha with slavery and Nazism by pointing out how some Asians and Africans were awarded honorary aryan status? Or how African monarchs sold subjects as slaves or how one American slave owner was a black himself? Now it’s woke of AI depicts those things lol
Honestly they should have just cranked it up. Fuck stereotypes, make it so that if you want a picture of a blonde haired, blue eyed man your prompt has to be something like "draw a picture of a typical Ethiopian".
I really hope this program isn’t doing the opposite and imposing white people in Black and Indigenous clothes and historical events, it’s funny when it’s happening to white people but in reverse it’s racism.
It's the same reason why some other generator would randomly print "ethnically ambigious" on some images or make Homer Simpson brown.
The instinct to challenge white as the default in media is nice I suppose, even if done poorly.
No they're not. If you want to make reference to the actual history of people who went a viking, then you can't do the "cool undercut" shit. You need that dude to have a fucked up skullet, and be wearing an old single color tunic under mail and half his weight in mismatched geegaws
Honestly, the re-imagining of our oppressors as ethnic minorities is somehow even more insulting than depicting a straight up white racist.
At least with the latter, it’s true to the historical nature of the oppression. What is this even trying to achieve? Normalizing the oppression being perpetrated by the very same minorities who were on the receiving end, so it’s not just white people who did the oppression in a twisted “revisionist” way?
I think the origin of this is Google noticing "oh, whenever we ask it to draw X profession, it just draws middle aged white men. We'll make it spit out different races to any prompt to fix this!"
so one part is just blind casting, which is good for actors/producers but can be a little frustrating if they're trying to make a historical story, not a huge deal tho in a lot of cases
but i think there is an insidious bit in shit like Hamilton when the casting is part of the politics of the show and that politics is one of lib conciliation/appropriation.