How is the New Planescape Book?
How is the New Planescape Book?
Ive Not followed the scene and Releases closely since a long time, but i remember the newer WotC releases being rather unsatisfying for the community. This Was due to a variety of reasons.
In vacuum Planescape should be my favorite DnD book but the quality of recent releaes aswell as the OGL disaster has disuaded me from purchasing any New books. How is your experience with the book and its contents?
People generally agree that the published adventure is in the middle of the pack, I personally don't run published adventures as I barely find time to get through my own adventures. If you don't run published adventures either, then that's 1/3rd of this content not appealing to you.
As with any monster book, your milage will vary with the usage and quality of each creature. 60 monsters is reasonable though, although if you're hankering for monsters alone, just head over to open5e.com, a collection of products released under various licenses, collated into searchable databases like D&DBeyond does with WotC content. There may be 1000+ high quality monsters there, and plenty that fit the tone of Planescape.
So finally there is the part that I'm most interested in, the setting guide. This slipcase in it's entirety is shorter than some previous setting guides were, so if you're after this specifically, you will be recieving 1/4 of the content than you would from one of the setting guides from earlier in 5e's lifespan like Eberron. If you're keen on this product as a Planescape fan, then this will appeal to you the most and, of course, it's shallow, because it has to be on its pagecount.
I want to love slipcases. My heart is forever at the physical table using hard cover books, even when practically I DM with a computer. The slipcase allows you to only bring what you need to each session and control what content you may pass to players without depriving yourself of anything. However for me to love them, they'd need to be 175% the size of the books from 2017, but instead with the larger font size and lower page count, they're 60% of the legnth. Also of course the price is higher than ever due to inflation, which is reasonable to price them effectively, but I have no more expendable cash than I did in 2017 and post the OGL fiasco, I'm far more likely to recommend non WotC 5e content which often prides itself on being denser and deeper than official content.
Great answer, thank you dor the effort. I actually have Not Heard of open5e.com, will definitly Check it out
Huge fan of the original Planescape. So much so that it overcame the distrust I had for WotC after all the OGL stuff. I picked it up and I have to say it reads as shallow. A lot of the names and content from AD&D version but written without giving any feeling to the setting created. I don’t recommend it.
Thats what i feared. Thank your for the answer
in my non-profressonal opinion, overall, its alright. Not great, not completely terrible. It's better than the spelljammer books they put out a while back, but it's far from the best they've done for 5e.
To quote Mike Shey, if you need to ask if it’s worth it, it probably isn’t.
I think his big takeaway is that it's relatively light on content for price. Especially compared to other books on sale on Amazon and such. Planescape has a lot of cardboard and not a lot of paper.
I gave my opinions about it here: https://youtu.be/_v-jnQCTZ1Q?si=yOklCEzs4gkqg4n1
Thank you for your answer i will check it out