Skip Navigation
13 comments
  • Among socialist countries, it's easily modern China but even then their finance sector is still mostly under Government control.

    No socialist country would come even close to the kind of financial excess like the US.

    • Makes sense... IDC if its under govt control, finance is finance

      • Ultimately there is always some financing. Erstwhile socialist countries also had a Ministry of Finance and a Central Bank (eg Gosbank). Workers have to be paid, they have to buy goods and services.

      • There's a pretty big qualitative difference between privately controlled central banks that safeguard the interests of the international bourgeoisie, like the US Federal Reserve, vs China's state operated financial ecosystem. China is ultimately not in the business of making money out of money, they use finance as a means to an end of mutual development with their trading partners.

  • It would also be China but if that answer is unsatisfying because China was already mentioned then probably Vietnam.

    This is vibes based analysis though, I don't have any data

  • I think the important thing to point out is that with Agriculture/Peasants and Industry/Proles, these represent a dialectic contradiction: within a mode of production there is an oppressing class and an oppressed class.

    A "Finance Socialist" state would not be run by the oppressors within the Financial system - it would be run by the oppressed. Just as the PRC is not ruled by landlords and the USSR was not ruled by Capitalists.

    Who exactly the oppressed class under the Public Finance mode of production (if it can even be considered a distinct mode of production) would be is the important question. I think as we transition deeper into a "Gig Economy" world, the answer is the Lumpenproletariat.

  • China again. Dedollarization will be very slow and very inevitable. There will never be a single moment for anyone to point to, just a gradual shift to where American sanctions have less and less of an effect. The Soviet Union would have made a very big deal out of reducing the influence of the dollar. China will shatter the dollar dependancy of the entire world and pretend like nothing happened. And no one else can point to it either, because if you point it out you make it worse. It is what I look forward to the most, even if I know I will never get a moment of triumph but instead at some point realize that this shift already happened years ago.

  • Easily Yugoslavia

13 comments