Temporary (mid-term) closure for forest-fire not allowed?
Temporary (mid-term) closure for forest-fire not allowed?
Hey guys.
There's a highway that connect the coast to inland, and without it drivers have a 4-hour detour. It has been closed for the past month while a forest fire has been fought by lots of fire crews. It's been burning since August 15th, so over a month now actually.
They've finally mitigated the fire enough that they are temporarily re-opening the highway, however it's remaining closed 8am - 4pm Mon-Fri so that the firemen are not blocked by congestion. When it's not closed between those hours, only 1 lane is open and traffic is led by patrol cars. There is no ETA for a full re-opening.
I went to go apply a condition, when I realized that no one had actually closed the road in the first place. So I added something like "conditional=no @ (Mon-Fri 8:00-16:00)" (I forget the exact syntax).
A day later, someone came in and reverted the change saying "the consensus is that only changes lasting 3 or more months should be made. There are people who download these maps for offline use. So no temporary closures."
But, the DOT of both states this fire is affecting are begging drivers to stop using GPS to the coast on this route - people are driving into active fire zones.
Does concession for offline users actually supersede safety?
Our map data is often downloaded and used offline on various devices for several weeks or months. For offline data to be useful, it should at least be expected to remain unchanged in the next few weeks when you map it.
yes, by this blurb, concession for offline users does supersede safety.
i'm an editor active enough to have been granted foundation membership but hadn't known this rule; it indicates a view of osm as analogous to a paper map rather than for real-time navigation. if a change of less than weeks' length is discouraged, i can't in good conscience steer my friends away from google maps, as navigation is not a primary use case.
Hmm, OSM is perhaps the biggest base for alternative navigational software. Seems like a huge design flaw.
I'm obviously oblivious to the implementation difficulties, but it seems like it should be extremely simple to add something akin to a "temporarily closed until" field, so that uses can set and forget, and it'll resolve itself without a secondary edit.
That way, offline users can ignore this field, and nav software must use it.
i am not sure it's a flaw at all. the conditional tag syntax is based on opening_hours, which should be able to express 'closed at these times until that date'. there are ways to finesse this. but as long as the published guideline is 'don't do this', there's little point pondering practical solutions.
@MrMusAddict @pootriarch within OSM, it's easy to add a tag like that. Alas, it's getting data users to _use_ that tag can be tricky...
You think about present users, but you should also think about the future. I found "temporarily" closed roads on osm which were forgotten. The road block lasted for a month irl, the editor forgot it and it remained closed for 6 years on the map. I found while debugging why a router was sending me a longer route.
Map software can add additional data, e.g. I know Magic Earth knows current road closures and traffic situations from different sources, it display them alongside the osm map, and considers them for routing.
It's also documented as a best practice: https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Good_practice#Don't_map_temporary_events_and_temporary_features
Permanently Deleted
Smith River Complex @ Gasquet Ranger District of the Six Rivers National Forest (SRF) - #SmithRiverComplex https://share.watchduty.org/i/10468
Permanently Deleted