Poland's Ministry of Family and Social Policy wants to ban employing foreigners under civil contracts, restricting them mostly to employment contracts
Poland's Ministry of Family and Social Policy wants to ban employing foreigners under civil contracts, restricting them mostly to employment contracts
The Ministry of Family and Social Policy argues this is necessary to protect Polish workers from unfair competition and to safeguard vulnerable immigrants.
Translation: we want to retain our whiteness.
Further context (in lib Polish): https://archive.is/LQlDe
What is the difference? The article does not explain
in essence, civil contracts is an umbrella term for two types of contracts: Contract of Mandate (Umowa zlecenie) and Contract for specific work (Umowa o dzieło). Employment contracts (umowa o pracę), which are its own category of contracts, are the regular employment contracts most people are familiar with.
Basically, the 1 major difference between the civil contracts and employment contracts is that you're entitled to benefits (overtime compensation, maternity/paternity leave, PTOs), work is done in specific work hours (up to 8 hours per day if I recall correctly) and are governed by the Labor Law (at the cost of taxes 😦), whereas the civil contract has none of those and are regulated under the Civil Code, with the benefit of having a higher take-home pay. Oh and either an employee or employer can terminate the agreement at any time under the civil contract.
The changes coming into effect at the start of 2025 concern employers not because this limits the opportunities of foreigners, surprise surprise, they don't give a fuck. They're concerned because this means they will lose out on $$$ that they save from not having to pay those benefits, and foreigners are concerned because this basically limits their options at getting anything resembling a job legally in a job market that's already in the crappiest state possible.
(source: https://polandunraveled.com/types-employment-contracts-poland/)
Employment contracts are protected under the labour laws and civil contracts are not. It's super rare in Poland good change.
Of course though, this is not the real reason neoliberal government is considering it. Real reason is that will pad up the retiremt system which is used more as a source to plug in the budget hole. The same move for the same reason was done years ago by PiS for Polish workers and it improved situation for both workers and budget (situation was so bad back then that around half of Polish workforce was "employed" on civil contracts, most of them with violation of multiple laws)