AdeptusPrimaris @ stmcld @lemmy.dbzer0.com

Posts

42

Comments

142

Joined

2 yr. ago

And Israel accused South Africa of being the legal arm of Hamas lol. Israel is really a joke of country right now. A genocidal joke of a country, to be sure, but still a joke.

You're mistaken. We don't have a hard on for the US and Israel.

The US: " we don't want an escalation of tensions in the middle east." The US then proceeds to escalate tensions in the middle east.

It's one of the most glaring examples of disconnect between what they're saying and what they're doing that I've seen.

The US is lying about their intent again to no one's surprise.

As a South African too, i will remain proud of South Africa for bringing this case of genocide against Israel.

You talk about motivations , so why didn't the US, UK or one of the European countries open a case of genocide against Israel?

If South Africa, with it's all its flaws, was able to bring a case of genocide against Israel, what does that say of those countries that couldn't do that. Those countries that purport to be defenders of human rights and freedom that are unable to mention crimes against humanity and Israel in the same sentence, let alone the word genocide.

This shows how despicable the motivations and thieving, murdering two-facedness of the US, UK and Europe are. The blatant hypocrisy and despicable motivations of these countries are far more damning than anything you accuse South Africa of.

The genocide convention is meant to be invoked when a group is at risk of genocide, before a genocide can be completed.

So yes, i will always be proud of South Africa for invoking the genocide convention against Israel, despite naysayers focusing on the imperfections of South Africa rather than the fact that South Africa is taking the correct course of action that is sorely needed despite it's imperfections or motivations.

Immensely proud of South Africa

No, of course not, Blinken said that calling it genocide is baseless and meritless /s

It's no problem. Maybe i can also be more clear too in the future when replying.

It's true that the Israeli citizens and the Palestinian citizens will have to be involved in a common solution. It will be very bitter, especially for the Palestinians, but one has to move forward

The settlers (aka colonolialist thieves and murderers) are literally killing, maiming, torturing Palestinians on their own land in the West Bank. Driving them out of their own houses, lands and farms. The Israeli army stands by and watches this. If any Palestinian tries to fight back against the settlers in the process of stealing their land they are maimed and/or murdered. And this is only in the West Bank where land theft and murder by the Israelis is still happening to this day. It doesn't include any of the other clear land theft that had taken place in historic Palestine by the Israelis.

Now tell me that is not similar to the Apartheid police force breaking into houses in your area and telling you to move or be murdered, because your property now belongs the Apartheid state that is going to parcel it out to the white Apartheid supporting citizens.

Finding similarities between the atrocities commited by the Apartheid South African government and the Apartheid Israeli government is not adding my country's baggage to a complex reality. A lot can be learnt by looking back at similar atrocities commited in the past and the repercussions of that, whay was learnt, etc.

Also an important point is that because of experiencing a similar repression of my people, parents, grandparents, and living through the tail end of that repression, i have empathy and some understanding of what the Palestinians are going through. I can't claim to know exactly how they're feeling but i do have some idea.

I have been campaigning in South Africa for Palestinian rights and self determination since i was a young teenager with my peers and my parents. I have been aware of the history, geopolitics and reality of the situation of the Palestinians since then. I have a pretty decent understanding of what is going on over there.

True. But i would add the extra detail that all the land stolen from Palestinians by Israel should be returned.

In South Africa that wasn't done. We had land and a house that my grandfather built up by himself in what is now one the most expensive suburbs in Cape Town. That land was stolen from us and never returned.

And it hurts so much everytime we have to go past there because there are rich white folks living there now. And we know we'll never be able to afford that land now no matter how hard we work. Now we struggle to even leave a home for our children to inherit.

I don't want that happening to the Palestinians again.

A Theocracy and an Ethnostate are two different things. If he meant theocracy he would have used the word theocracy, but he didn't. He used the word ethnostate

Exactly. It like watching the US back in the 2000's constantly talk about WMDs as a pretext to attack and destabilise the middle east once again.

What's the view your side on what the US and Israel are doing?

It seems to me that the US keeps trying to link absolutely anything done by Qassam brigades and Hezbollah and others to Iran. They're constantly mentioning Iran. And they're trying to make sure people think of Hamas as the same as Isis, when they're totally different ideologically.

I feel like the reason that the US is delaying any de-escalation by Israel is that the US is hoping that Israel attacks Iran and Lebanon and that those countries respond. And by doing so it gives the US an excuse to attack and take control of those countries under the guise of helping an ally.

There was a really intersting opinion piece that made a lot of sense to me, I'll try to link it.

https://www.nakedcapitalism.com/2024/01/prof-michael-hudson-world-predictions-for-2024-usa-un-palestine-russia-and-brics.html

Hey that would be nice, i hope a community like that does pop up too. I want to actually start learning it as well

As horrible as South African apartheid was, what is happening to the Palestinans is degrees worse.

Ordinary South Africans still remember the deep damage Apartheid perpetrators inflicted on us, it's poisonous remnants are still affecting us as a country to this day as we try to heal as a people.

Now imagine South Africans seeing what Israel is perpetrating against the Palestinians, now and in the past. It's a punch to the gut, a searing pain, to see what was done to us and our parents being done to Palestinians. We're seeing a gross refined version of Apartheid that was inflicted on us being inflicted on the Palestinians. And largely the so called west/ global north is cheering for the Israeli Apartheid regime commiting genocide. It makes me sick to my core.

For these reasons there is immense pressure on our government by civil society to denounce Israel and support Palestine. It does help that the ANC has always been pro Palestinian in the first place. Also it's elections this year so the ANC definitely wants some good pr too.

I would say that these points factor in way more than any link to Russia or China

Yes that's true, i noticed that too. But that community is for world news, not just US news.

I mean i understand posting about US news a few times, but he is flooding the community twice a day with between maybe 10 to 15 posts all about US internal news. I might be over- or underestimating but I'm not going to go back to count.

It's been horrible, he's been flooding the zone with shit ever since he's been demodded here.

Is that why he's spamming !politics@lemmy.ml with US internal news lately? The place has been terrible to navigate now.

I just find it ironic that the mods here implemented a rule that forbids spamming of posts by one person. Then this former mod? goes on to do exactly that at !politics@lemmy.ml

Spamming the comment section with pro israeli comments or even just muddying the waters. I've seen it with a few posters, including rivermonster. It distracts those reading from the real issue being discussed, usually israeli crimes against humanity.

I think you meant descendants. But yep, extremely ironic and disgusting.

Fucking hell. The US should be charged with warcrimes and crimes against humanity right alongside israel if they insist again and again on being complicit in these atrocities

As a South African i couldn't have said it better myself. Israelis and israeli apologists i notice get very offended when you compare israel to Apartheid South Africa, i mean the parallels are so clear to see.