These Climate Activists Make People Uncomfortable -- And It's Working

www.rollingstone.com

34 comments

Godspeed
Is this a vegan org? It doesn't mention anything about their members adhering to a plant-based diet, and it would certainly make me uncomfortable if they weren't.
- Adhering to dogmatic ideas of ideological purity is detrimental to the environmentalist cause.
- Along with what others have said, you’re also falling for the oil industry’s years long campaign to heave onto us the responsibility to fix the mess they created, knew about, covered up, and gaslighted everyone on.
  A group is having a real impact on the people and companies that are 85%-95% responsible for the mess we’re in…and you question the climate group? Like…that’s such weirdly unnecessary bootlicking. You probably don’t realize you’re doing it—or maybe you do, I dunno. But this is the same tactic used every single time a reporter is trying to discredit a spokesperson for any climate action group—the shitty conservative reporters too, like Pierce Morgan.
  So…you’re not in good company.
  
  You can find other orgs that fight against climate change who promote veganism within their organization and to the general population. Greenpeace, for example. Hell, even Greta Thunberg, who's had more of an impact than these other guys, is vegan.
  The idea is to "be the change", and you can't be telling one group (i.e. the fossil fuel industry) to stop doing what they are doing, while acting in ways that demonstrably harm the environment needlessly.
  A plant-based diet, perhaps above all else, is one of the most powerful tools we have to fight climate change. And once you convince one person to go vegan, they will likely change their lifestyle beyond diet to reduce their carbon footprint and rely less on the fossil fuel industry.
  The industry won't go anywhere if they still have 8 billion customers. As individuals, our day-to-day lives impact their bottom line; we can make them money, or we can prevent them from making money.
  I don't discredit their efforts, but their credibility. It would go a long way if their members showed that they were serious about climate change in their own lives, while fighting against the industry.
  Anyway, I just asked the question, since I don't know this group. Perhaps they are all vegans, and they go after the livestock industry, too.
- and it would certainly make me uncomfortable if they weren't.
  I was going to be very mean to you, then I took a deep breath and realized that it wasn't worth it.
  I would invite you to realize that for every 10 articles detailing how bad climate change is, there are maybe 1 of these articles. Tell me, what exactly are you doing by poking holes here? This organization has the potential to create far more lasting change than you being vegan ever will. What do you gain by pointing this out?
- While going vegan is a good thing for the environment, not everyone can or is willing to switch completely. You can reduce your meat intake and eating more plant based foods without going full vegan.
  Don't let perfect be the enemy of good enough, especially at an individual level.
  
  I mean if you feel better you do it, but actual actions regarding the climate would be laws that force the industry to act on their emissions.
  Which in return will make meat more expensive and therefore people will eat less.
  
  While going vegan is a good thing for the environment
  It's quite literally one of the most impactful things you can do as an individual.
  not everyone can or is willing to switch completely.
  99.99% of people can, but an org that's fighting to end climate change really should have that be their minimum for members.
  Greenpeace, for example, promotes veganism all the time. I'd trust them more than these other guys.
- The article is about fighting oil and gas and you bring up veganism and state that if they're not vegans they aren't truly fighting for the cause?? Defeating oil and gas would be a great thing for the world and being vegan has nothing to do with any of it. But way to keep your eye on the prize Showroom. They certainly can't lobby to make the world a better place if they eat chicken nuggets from time to time. The Audacity of these people.
  
  I was actually asking about the values of the group, not the article specifically.
  From what I understand (after reading the group's website), is that they aren't only against oil and gas but all forms of industry and government leaders who can impact climate change.
  Their posted values include “peacefulness”, which is in line with the vegan movement.
  Their posted values also include “solidarity”, and explains that they “stand with” other movements, including racial and economic justice. This is also in line with the vegan movement.
  I was merely curious, since veganism would be a great fit for the members of that group. It would certainly elevate their credibility.
- Oh noes, that organization that really makes an impact in bettering the world doesn't support my particular pet peeve, they suck!
  It's this attitude why most grass roots organisations fail. As soon as a group gains some traction, you have all these.peoplemlike you immediately trying to inject their issues in there. I remember this happening to occupy Wall Street, that started good, then it toren itself apart when they needed to add all the other issues, racism, lgbtqfjwkskgr, Womens rights, animal rights, and so on... Meanwhile the coke sniffing assholes were laughing at them from a high balcony with champagne in their claws I shit you not.
  How about you just tell them: well done, please do some more! Can I help you with your cause? Maybe one day we'll look at my particular cause, but that can wait a day.
  Your behavior is the reason why we can't have nice things, please stop it
  
  I think you've missed the point. I merely asked if this climate change organization promoted veganism, since other climate change groups do, and it seems to be in line with their message.
  If they aren't, why not?
  It's good to ask questions, friend. If not, you might as well listen to industry propaganda, since values don't matter anyway.
- Do you do CrossFit too?
- I use Arch btw
- Perfection is the enemy of progress.
  Everyone who ever got anything done.
  Progress is the enemy of perfection.
  Showroom7561
  
  Thank you
- They're not really trying to change minds, they're just crashing fossil fuel parties. We'll have to see if they crash meat industry parties too. I doubt it.
  It's pretty common for people to fail at understanding systemic problems, unfortunately. We'll see what other groups do after this one fails and disbands.
  
  You want people crashing meat industry parties? Get your friends to join you and do exactly that.
- One of the biggest things you can do to dilute your message as a group, especially a small group, is to choose too many targets. As you said elsewhere, Greenpeace is already promoting veganism, as is PETA and a number of other groups. These guys don't need to jump on that bandwagon to get the message out. Let them focus on what they're doing, which also needs to be done. Otherwise, all you're doing is redirecting criticism from the bad actors to the people trying to make them stop.