The Terrible Costs of a Phone-Based Childhood
The Terrible Costs of a Phone-Based Childhood
The environment in which kids grow up today is hostile to human development.
By a variety of measures and in a variety of countries, the members of Generation Z (born in and after 1996) are suffering from anxiety, depression, self-harm, and related disorders at levels higher than any other generation for which we have data.
You're viewing part of a thread.
You're literally doing the thing you accuse others of—jumping to conclusions without full evidence. Declaring ADHD purely genetic, while ignoring potential environmental factors, is a leap without scientific backing. It’s not about muddling waters; it’s about acknowledging our current limits and exploring all possibilities. That’s the essence of true scientific inquiry.
I believe things that are proven. Claiming ADHD is environmental without proof is on the same scale as "Vaccines cause Autism" and is used to claim shit like "Everyone has ADHD these days" or find something to blame for "causing ADHD" without ever supporting actual people with ADHD. The OP was literally using this exact argument to blame electronics for causing ADHD! This is muddying the waters and is not helping people with ADHD at all and is probably just harming them.
Dismissing the role of environmental factors in ADHD overlooks the basic science that our behaviours and surroundings can fundamentally alter brain function. It's a leap to equate cautious exploration of these effects with debunked myths.
What else? Environmental factors cause Autism too? Maybe they cause homosexuality as well? If you think this is the case either make studies or point to studies that base this theory. Just because environmental factors can alter brain function, it doesn't mean every disorder or behaviour is potentially generated by environmental factors!
Is this really your response?
Nobody said environmental factors "cause ADHD"; this debate is about whether environmental factors can amplify presentation of executive dysfunction type symptoms in the genetically predisposed.
Just because environmental factors can alter brain function, it doesn't mean every disorder or behaviour is potentially generated by environmental factors!
No, but it does mean that it is incredibly unlikely that they are not sometimes exacerbated by environmental factors.
Nobody said environmental factors “cause ADHD”; this debate is about whether environmental factors can amplify presentation of executive dysfunction type symptoms in the genetically predisposed.
You're not "genetically predisposed" to ADHD. It's not an allergy or cancer. Either you have it, or you don't.
No, but it does mean that it is incredibly unlikely that they are not sometimes exacerbated by environmental factors.
Everything is exacerbated by environmental factors. Why single out ADHD here?
Environmental factors (screen time) while a child's sensory apparatus is not fully developed has been linked to development of ADHD and Autism.
https://www.earth.com/news/toddler-screen-time-linked-to-atypical-sensory-behaviors/
"Linked" is a stretch. From that article (which is about <2 yo btw) it is talking about a mere correlation of a behaviour which might (they don't know) exacerbate ADHD or Autistic people. If I understood it correctly, It's also a study based on self-reporting from caretakers
It's also a study based on self-reporting from caretakers
Is this better or worse than other forms of self-reporting?
As cool as technologies like fMRI are, we have not reached any meaningful degree of objectivity in most psychological/neurological pursuits.
I'm sorry, was that a refutation?