Android @lemdro.id Moonrise2473 @feddit.it 9 mo. ago

Gemini on Android can't ID songs, and it's frustrating | TechCrunch

techcrunch.com Gemini on Android can't ID songs, and it's frustrating | TechCrunch

Google's Gemini chatbot falls short in a number of areas. One of them is recognizing songs that might be playing.

The author says that once you install Gemini (pro), when you ask "what song is this", you get a reply like "use apple's Shazam".

They say Google assistant music recognition was working so well and super accurate.

Although I was never able to have it work. When I ask "what song is this" I can only get one of this two results:

Sorry, I didn't understand (90% of cases)
Search "what song is this" on Google

My use cases are:

In car listening to radio. I never have it work.
Know which song is playing right now on the device when I'm using headphones. It never worked but it should be trivial, you already have all the metadata already. My iPod touch could do this super reliably and 100% offline TWENTY YEARS ago. It was so useful.

29 comments

I was surprised to find Gemini had replaced assistant. It couldn't even add items to the shopping list. Thankfully one is able to revert the change.
- Gemini can't do a damn thing. It's completely useless as a digital assistant. It can't even play music on YouTube Music. Who thought it would be a good idea to replace the Google Assistant with this?
So you can't ID songs either?
- Yeah but I'm not going around boasting that I can.
https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=com.rocketsauce83.musicsearch
- Don't need to install a dedicated third party app for that, the Google app already exposes a widget for sound search
I'm always using assistant to play music in the car or on home speakers. Gemini isn't able to do this. I also discovered I can't use the Gemini app without allowing it to replace the assistant.

I will say I have had similar problems getting assistant to identify songs. It used to work pretty seamlessly.

Against all privacy recommendations I do allow my phone to id music at all times. Nice thing is I have a shortcut to history, it doesn't always work, bit does most of the time.
Permanently Deleted
wow - surely not being able to recognize songs totally defeats the purpose of an assistant

/s

Shazam solved music recognition 20y ago, just stop whining and use a tool that has this feature.

That's like complaining my coffee maker doesn't make tea.
- Google Assistant could do it.
  
  So it’s more like complaining that your coffee maker stopped making the water hot.
  
  Pixels just do it automatically on the lock screen, no need for assistant, or even going online, it works just on the phone.
  
  A better comparison would be that your coffee maker's RGB light no longer supports a specific off-shade of pink.
  
  and GA is still available, just use it
- Google assistant is already almost useless (at least in my language, I get almost always a "sorry, I didn't understand" answer, but your mileage may vary), a newer version that can't interact with anything seems pointless.
  
  "Send Whatsapp to..." - "I can't interact with Whatsapp"
  
  "Turn off the lights" - "I don't have access to this"
  
  "Identify this song" - "use our competitor's app"
  
  GA was amazing years ago, it’s gotten consistently worse over time to the point I’ve stopped using it in my home for anything other than asking today’s weather when I wake up.

You've viewed 29 comments.