You're viewing part of a thread.
Your position from the first comment is free will and determinism both exist.
Are you sure about that?
4 0 ReplyDialectical materialism holds that both are at work but that material conditions are dominant.
Am I supposed to take "both" to not include "free will?"
1 0 ReplyYou're supposed to review your claim to see whether it's accurate.
4 0 ReplyWhat claim do you want me to review?
1 0 ReplyThe one I quoted
3 0 ReplyI stand behind my impression that “both” was intended to mean that diamat is ultimately compatiblist. A claim I disagree with, as I am not a compatiblist, yet I see no conflict between that and my dialectical materialist outlook.
1 0 ReplyDo you really not know what I'm challenging you on?
3 0 ReplyThe question is not yet settled by simply debunking religious dogma?
1 0 ReplyI guess that's a yes lol
3 0 ReplyThis conversation has gone all over the place, I don't know what point you were originally trying to make.
1 0 Reply