World News @lemmy.world MicroWave @lemmy.world 10 mo. ago

Germany Rejects UN 'Genocide' Charge Against Israel

www.barrons.com Germany Rejects UN 'Genocide' Charge Against Israel

The German government on Friday sharply rejected allegations before the UN's top court that Israel is committing "genocide" in Gaza and warned against "political instrumentalisation" of the charge.

58 comments

Germany knows a thing or two about genocide so it's surprising they're not seeing it in Gaza.
- Germany is so ashamed of its history that no Israel atrocity can change that.
  
  They're not ashamed. Germans still hate Jews. The initial plan Hitler had was to move all the Jews to Madagascar.
  
  The Madagascar Plan was a plan proposed by the Nazi German government to forcibly relocate the Jewish population of Europe to the island of Madagascar. Franz Rademacher proposed the idea in June 1940
  
  The Zionist thing is an easy excuse to make the Palestinians responsible for German crimes. Germany doesn't want israelis moving back.
  
  The second reason Germany is simping this hard is that Germany wants Intel, which is an israeli company, to build more chip factories there. Thus they have to bow their heads to Zionists. Buy AMD kids.
- There are still a lot of old people in Germany who refuse to say anything negative about Israel.
- They can never, ever take a position against Israel.
  
  We can, we should and we must at this point.
  
  Germany takes plenty of positions against Israel. You're confusing us with the US.
- I think they are calling them weak. I figured it would be but when you put it in comparison we are almost there but not quite to the same level
- Western countries records of respecting human rights are nothing but performative theater. They are part of the same imperialist empire. of which they all benefit from.
  
  Sure are painting a lot of people with the one brush there buddy. I've never invaded anyone.
- It's exactly because they know a thing or two they're not willing to throw the term around willy-nilly
  
  What's happening in Gaza right now isn't a genocide. It's awful, they are commiting warcrimes, but not a genocide.
  
  Funnily enough, what's happening in the West Bank has better Chances of being classified as a Genocide. Yet all those "Experts" on the Internet never talk about that. They only see civilian houses blowing up, then they take the worst word they know, "genocide", and call it that.
  
  Do you think Palestinians in Gaza will ever be able to return home, in the near or far future, without being killed under the excuse of "it's an evacuation zone, so they must be Hamas"?
  
  And do you think the "evacuation zone" will ever stop expanding before it encompasses the entirety of Gaza?
  
  Because I'm pretty sure forcefully displacing a people from their home and not allowing them to return qualifies as genocide.
- Is it possible that my opinion about Israel is wrong? No, it must be Germany who is wrong!
  
  Yeah... sure... because Israel has been acting so nicely for decades now
- Indeed they do and they acknowledge their history, and why this doesn't apply:
  
  In light of German history and the crimes against humanity of the Shoah, the German government is particularly committed to the (UN) Genocide Convention," signed in 1948 in the wake of the Holocaust, Hebestreit said.
  He said the Convention marked a "central instrument" under international law to prevent another Holocaust.
  For this reason, he said, "we stand firmly against a political instrumentalisation" of the Convention.
  Hebestreit acknowledged diverging views in the international community on Israel's military operation in Gaza.
  "However the German government decisively and expressly rejects the accusation of genocide brought against Israel before the International Court of Justice," he said. "The accusation has no basis in fact."
  
  Seems like they got it right.
  
  They didn't actually present any argument that this isn't a genocide, nor did they even try to address anything the South African delegation have presented. This is state speech for "nuh uh", so the only reason you could see that "they got it right" was if you just liked their conclusion.
"We're so sorry we killed 6 million Jews we gave them a genocide on credit"
Spineless cucks should have abstained.

Fuck Hamas, but what is happening in Gaza is absolutely genocide. Trying to diplomatically meander around that is fucking pathetic.
... There's a Nazi joke in there somewhere.
- The joke is that the jews in Israel are taking plays right out of the nazi handbook while Germany bends over backwards to appease these people.
- But I'm not seeing it.
Once again, Germany looks away from a clear and blatant genocide. It's almost like they're known for that or something.
- stop using the word genocide willy-nilly. You're essentially the Boy who cries Wolf.
  
  What happens in Gaza is awful and there are definitely WarCrimes. But a Genocide is on a whole other Level.
  
  Nope. It's a genocide under the UN definition which is the agreed international definition.
Cool. Fuck Germany.
- Cool. Fuck you.
Never stopped sucking Zionist balls since the end of WWII.

Thank skies I haven't considered Germany as a destination country.
- Please also don't come to Switzerland. Don't want you here either.
  
  I can't afford you anyways, so rest assured.
A Stop the genocide in Gaza graffiti was sprayed onto my university a few days ago (Germany I should mention). Uni tried to cover it up but it's currently on display at the busiest part of the campus and I predict it will stay there for a while

You've viewed 58 comments.