I mean, if I beheaded a Jesus I would expect a slap on the wrist for destruction of property.
I’d argue the purpose of putting that up in the first place was to have it vandalized. As a card carrying member of the Satanic Temple, I assure you, we are all giggling.
I tried finding more analogous examples, but it seems like most of the nativity vandals get away with their crimes. I found several news stories, but they always end with "police are hoping the public might have more info..."