It's seriously hilarious to me that something like Linux will literally let you uninstall the bootloader and reboot without installing a new one and won't say shit about it. :D
It's by design. What if I boot from USB? Then what's on the disk is irrelevant. I can boot a kernel off a USB drive and chroot into any drive i feel like. Hell, I could boot from a USB and then chroot into my broken drive and reinstall the bootloader without having to reinstall the OS.
Lets see MS pull that off. I bet once you corrupt the registry enough you have no choice but to reformat and start over.
You can’t even put /Users fully onto a second drive without hacks that potentially break Windows Update because they can’t even be arsed to use their own environment variables or follow mounts.
“Reformatting huh? Hope you had a backup of all your documents, lol. Hey why not try OneDrive only $199 a year bro”
There used to be a native tool called Windows Easy Transfer, but it was dropped in Windows 10 in favor of third-party tools like PCmover and transwiz. There is still Microsoft's USMT, but that's designed as an enterprise tool and I think it depends on MECM.
Similarly, in Linux, I've seen issues like a chown/chmod gone wild that fucked the system file permissions enough that reinstalling is the easiest course of action.
Yep I'm well aware. I jumped on the Linux train awhile ago. It's so freeing.
I remember when you could uninstall Internet Explorer on your own as a regular ass user. Now? Get rekt idiot you're stuck with Edge on your system and we're gonna regularly reset it as your default browser.
What hardcore Linux users don't seem to really get is this: The vast majority of people who need to use computers simply do not care about anything you just said. They absolutely don't. They simply want to press a button to boot the device, use the apps they need and maybe even play a game and that's it. That is what Windows does for them.
The average user is overwhelmed when the desktop icons have been moved.
I love Linux and it is on a great way to being used by a wider audience and it's great it provides the freedom it does. But it still has its quirks that makes it too hard to use for 95% of users.
But the average user is not going to uninstall their bootloader to begin with. We were talking about power users. As a power user it's nice to be able to do whatever you want.
If that happens, there are people like you and I who are into that shit. And it's great that there are alternatives that can help out in such a case. I don't know how to fix more complex issues on my motorcycle, that's when I ask my friends or my mechanic to fix it for me.
Yeah well, I don't care either..? She probably doesn't need to most of the time? So the one time she does, she goes to a shop or asks her grandson who is good with them darn computers.
You know when Linux really started to become more popular? When it dumbed stuff down and made things easier out of the box. It's great that it is still so flexible. But you don't draw in the masses with the argument that you can reinstall the bootloader if you want. You draw in the masses with a nicely designed and easy to use GUI. Simple as that.
I'm not defending Windows. I fucking hate what they do. But Linux Gurus also need to understand that there are two kinds of people - those who want to fully control the OS - and those that simply want to use it.