FREEMEDIAHECKYEAH @lemmy.fmhy.ml SatisfyingOrange @lemmy.fmhy.ml 1 yr. ago

Now that mullvad has ended support for port forwarding, where should one go for P2P ?

I wanted to do some soulseek, but just as I began moving towards that this happened. What VPN should I use for this ? I don't want to use any of those over advertised shady VPNs like nordvpn (who was a spamming machine on my PC back when I used it) or surfshark or others if not necessary...

49 comments

honestly you are going to be fine with most VPN providers. Unless you are one of the members of the very big scene groups, you are just seeding and your threat model is just to mask your connections from your ISP.

I personally suggest to use njalla. Few people talk about it but it's a very very good provider, better than mullvad imho. Allows port forwarding, is transparent about legal requests and have a history of support with the piratebay. On top of that paypal denied payments to them for a period, and that is usually a good sign
- I personally suggest to use njalla. Few people talk about it but it’s a very very good provider, better than mullvad imho. Allows port forwarding
  
  That's interesting, their website barely mentions any features about the VPN so I had assumed they don't offer port forward. Just curious
  
  How many port forwards do they offer?
  
  Is it a static or dynamic port forward number? e.g. do they automatically change the number on you after x amount of time or does the port number stay the same?
  
  How do you configure the port forward on their system? Can it be configured on their website? Or must it be done via a VPN application they offer, or some other way?
  
  Since my airvpn test month expired, I've just bought a Njalla subscription. Here are my experiences:
  
  Pro:
  
  Payment via PayPal or cryptocurrency
  
  Same price as Mullvad (5€/month)
  
  Static IPv4 and v6, allows you to forward any port
  
  Torrenting just worked (including port forwarding)
  
  No VPN application, just use vanilla OpenVPN or Wireguard
  
  Does not throttle my internet speed (I only have 50MBit/s, so I cannot really test VPN performance. Definitely better than AirVPN though)
  
  Contra:
  
  Requires E-Mail address/XMPP to create an account
  
  Only one client. If you need to access your VPN from multiple devices at the same time, you need to buy multiple subscriptions
  
  Only Swedish servers
  
  Conclusion: for my usecase (Raspberry-Pi-based torrent box) Njalla looks great. If you want to use it on multiple devices or need to circumvent geoblocks, you should look for a different service.
like nordvpn (who was a spamming machine on my PC back when I used it) or surfshark

Just FYI neither of those has port forwarding.
ProtonVPN, AirVPN and PIA all support port forwarding iirc
- thanks, I'll try Air.
I'm a bit confused. Using mullvad and I'm still seeding fine.

Could anyone explain why I need portforwarding?

Using mullvad wireguard and qbittorrent

Seeding with ~1Mbit right now, which is normal for my connection

Edit: thought soulseek is some torrent slang or client, I'm an idiot ^^
- OP wants to use Soulseek which is P2P and requires port forwarding.
  
  The post doesn't mention seeding or torrenting whatsoever mate
  
  Oh God I'm an idiot. Thanks
- you don't really have a high bandwidth so I am not surprised that it makes no difference. For me port forwarding is the difference between seeding at 16MB/s vs 3/4MB/s
  
  Does it only take affect seeding? I'm behind NAT with no port forwarding and often download at 80-110 MB/s (megabytes, not megabits).
AirVPN and proton vpn can both do port forwarding
I've been an avid user of Windscribe for years. Works great and has great customer support. From what I can tell they also respect your privacy.
I'm in a similar boat, loved mullvad for years but disappointed to see port forwarding go.
Not sure how tech savvy are you, but you can get any VPS with public IP anywhere in the world, you can spin up a simple docker container and create a wireguard tunnel, for example https://github.com/wg-easy/wg-easy after that a simple port forward and you are good to go... or just connect other devices to the same network, and have them communicate through your own VPN between each other...

Any reputable VPS provider will not spy on your systems, so its even more secure than any VPN you can get. And if you need another IP/exit location, copy the folder with your docker compose file, shutdown one VPS, start another in different location, run one command to install docker, copy the directory and start it up.
Dude still seems to be updating this; though, there doesn't look to be a column detailing port forwarding. Maybe look into a few of these that look good?

https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1s_o8QioqAILThKD04FYT95jI1siTOX5L/edit?pli=1#gid=1387289544
- It was a good chart but stopped being updated around 2018/2019. I don't remember the specifics but IIRC the owner (That One Privacy Guy) sort of ran out of time / retired from doing that stuff. He was also active on Reddit moderating VPN subs for a while & was great at keeping out the VPN spammers/shills there.
  
  He had his own website that was bought by SafetyDetectives (a spammy ranking / affiliate linking site) so for a while people were worried that the new owners would break the VPN google doc with paid referral listings & whatnot. Kind of disappointing that it would be bought by a company clearly promoting the opposite of what That One Privacy Guy was working towards.
  
  I'm not sure if that Google Doc you linked is a copy, or maybe the last version that existed. It was never totally clear if SafetyDetectives actually got control of the Google Doc but the rest is history now.
  
  Pretty certain I linked the new one. Shows created January 2022 and last updated May 2023.
  
  EDIT: Weird the last updated cell does show 2019, but looking at the docs metadata through Google drive shows Jan 2022 and May 2023. You may be right though, this could be stale.
Private internet access.com has port forwarding.
- PIA went bad. Got bought by a new owner.
  
  Ugh. The death of reliable VPNs it seems.
would NOT recommend protonvpn since it's the same company running protonmail, which has a history of bad security and has given private mails to governments. plus their free plan is pretty bad and doesn't have port forwarding. but it's an unpopular opinion ig.

anyways, i've been using airvpn and it's been fairly good. some other ones include:

windscribe

torguard

cryptostorm
- The problem is you say all that then recommend PIA. Another company known for being shady af. Proton ultimately is still under Europol laws but they have an onion site and you can pay in crypto
  
  I'd like to see your sources on that statement.
  
  PIA has literally gone to US federal court at least twice, and prevailed both times proving they had no logs to share with authorities.
  
  PIA has an actual track record of privacy protection success, which is something few other VPN providers have.
  
  I didn't know about PIA and never "recommended." I just listed a few other services that I knew had port forwarding. I removed it from the comment.
- 💀 Source for them giving private emails to governments ?? Your emails are E2EE they don't have the ability to decrypt them when you hold the keys. The most they did AFAIK is IP log a user because they had to comply with swiss law. Their VPN has no logs & has been audited

You've viewed 49 comments.