me_irl
me_irl
66 comments
-
I mean... Those things are all skills. They are skills anyone can develop barring some kind of disability (you're probably not gonna be singing if you don't have a larynx, for example).
-
maybe they could learn to whistle? Does that require a larynx? For that matter, does whistle count as singing? Now I have so many questions.
-
That's a good question. Personally, I think it should but I am pretty sure I've seen it classified as playing an instrument once.
-
I guess it's really no different than a flute... I also can't play a flute worth a shit as well as whistling so yeah. Makes sense as an instrument.
-
Whistling has a lot in common with other wind instruments as well. Oral cavity control, resonance, air use and ear training etc. Just the vibrating element changes and you'll have a tool that provides a resonating air column and projection and other things. And music is music, of course. That's overlap in itself.
-
-
-
What? Of course it requires a larynx. Where do you think the whistle is produced from? It's air.
-
-
66 comments